New study shows significant undercounting of Indigenous peoples in Winnipeg
A new study published in the International Journal of Environmental Research found about 300,000 First Nations and Métis people live in Winnipeg, nearly three times more than the 2021 Census count of 90,535. The findings reinforce previous research showing a pattern of census undercounting of Indigenous peoples in urban centres across Canada.
Study findings
- Using a respondent-driven sampling survey and population estimation methods, researchers estimated about 300,000 First Nations and Métis people live in Winnipeg, compared with the 2021 Census count of 90,535.
- This means the actual Indigenous population in Winnipeg may be more than three times larger than official census figures suggest. This finding reinforces previous research from showing a pattern of census undercounting of First Nations, Inuit and Métis peoples living in urban centres across Canada.
Why this matters
- Accurate population counts are critical for measuring health needs and outcomes. When population sizes are underestimated, health indicators, service utilization rates, and comparisons across regions and over time can be distorted.
- The undercount has real implications for funding and service delivery. An inaccurate understanding of the size of urban Indigenous populations can result in insufficient health services, resources, and programs for communities that may have much greater needs than official data indicates.
Recommendations
- Researchers say improvements can include stronger partnerships with Indigenous organizations, adding Indigenous identity questions to short-form census participation and coverage measures, and improving data collection for people living in collective housing or experiencing housing insecurity. Better counting would support more equitable, culturally relevant health planning and resource allocation.
Quotes:
“This study reflects the reality we at the Aboriginal Health & Wellness Centre of Winnipeg see every day as a healthcare and service provider. It reinforces the need to ensure Indigenous-led agencies have the resources and capacity to meet the true scale and complexity of our relative’s needs.”
-Monica Cyr, Chief Executive Officer, Aboriginal Health and Wellness Centre of Winnipeg
“This study underscores the importance of accurate, meaningful data to understand the health and social needs of First Nations people living in urban centres. When our populations are significantly undercounted, it can lead to gaps in funding, services and health planning. First Nations-led research and data sovereignty are essential to ensuring that our communities have a voice in how data about our people is collected, interpreted and used. Data must reflect the realities of First Nations people and support decisions that improve health outcomes, strengthen services and address the needs of our communities.”
Chief Sheldon Kent, Chairperson of the First Nations Health and Social Secretariat of Manitoba Board
“The majority of First Nations and Metis peoples now live in cities. This study demonstrates once again what Indigenous service providers have been telling us for decades – that the Indigenous population counts used for urban planning are striking underestimates of the true population size.”
– Dr Janet Smylie MD MPH, Tier CRC in Advancing Generative Health Services for Indigenous Populations in Canada, Director, Well Living House, St. Michael’s Hospital Research Institute, Unity Health Toronto
Professor, DLSPH and DFCM, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto
About “The Right to Be Counted: Unmasking First Nations and Métis Population Undercounts in Winnipeg, Manitoba”
This study was led by researchers at Well Living House at St. Michael’s Hospital in partnership with the Aboriginal Health and Wellness Centre and the First Nations Health and Social Secretariat in Manitoba.
